Welcome to roadstat.com on July 6 2009.
This is an internet experiment running to monitor browsing habbits of individuals through wikipedia contents.

List of megalithic sites

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to: navigation, search

This is a list of ancient sites that moved megalithic stones, organized according to the size of the largest megalith on the site. A megalith is a large stone which has been used to construct a structure or monument, either alone or together with other stones. In all cases at least one colossal stone over ten tons has been moved to create the structure or monument. Documented in recent times, there is a list of efforts to move colossal stones that used technology that wasn't more advanced than the technology the ancient civilizations used. In most cases the ancient civilizations had little, if any, advanced technology that would help the moving of these megaliths. The most notable exception is that of the ancient Greeks and Romans who had cranes and treadwheels to help lift colossal stones. Most of these weights are based on estimates by published scholars however there have been numerous false estimates of many of these stones presented as facts. To help recognize exaggerations there is also a brief description of how to calculate the weight of colossal stones by calculating volume and density.

Contents

[edit] List of megalithic sites

[edit] List of efforts to move and install stones

For additional details of most experiments see related pages.

  • In 1997 Julian Richards teamed up with Mark Witby and Roger Hopkins to conduct several experiments to replicate the construction at Stonehenge for NOVA's "Secrets of Lost Empires" mini series. They initially failed to tow a 40 ton megalith with 130 men but after adding additional men towing as well as some men using levers to prod the megalith forward they succeeded in inching it forward a small distance.[70]
  • Josh Bernstein and Julian Richards organized an effort to pull a 2 ton stone on wooden tracks with a group of about 16 men. Approximately 8 men pulled each ton. [71]
  • Thor Heyerdahl organized an effort to pull a 10 ton Moai on a sledge with a group of 180 men. Approximately 18 men pulled each ton. [72][73][74]
  • Mark Lehner and NOVA organized an experiment to tow stones and to build a pyramid 9 meters wide by 9 meters deep by 6 meters high. They were able to tow a 2 ton block on a sledge across wood tracks with 12 to 20 men. Approximately 6 to 10 men pulled each ton. The pyramid was 54 cubic meters total estimated weight 135 tons. It was built out of 186 stones. The average weight of each stone was almost 1,500 lb (680 kg). (.75 tons) They found that 4 or 5 men could use levers to flip stones less than a ton and roll them to transport them. 44 men took 22 days to complete the pyramid including the carving of the stones. They used iron to carve the stones that wasn't available to the ancient Egyptians. Egyptians had to use copper. They also used a modern front end loader to accelerate the work on the lower courses. They were unable to use the front end loader to install the capstone since it was too high and had to use levers to raise it to 20 feet (6.1 m). [75]
  • Henri Chevrier organized an effort to pull a 6 ton block on a sledge with a group of 6 men. Approximately 1 man pulled each ton. [76] other reports claim that Chevier's experiment required 3 men to pull each ton. [77]
  • Giovanni Battista Belzoni organized an effort to pull a 7.5 ton fragment of a statue of Ramses on rollers with a group of 130 men in 1815. This statue was towed to the river and loaded on a barge where it was sent to London. Progress increased with practice as they went along. Approximately 17 or 18 men pulled each ton. [78]
  • Henry Layard organized an effort to transport 2 10 ton colossal Statues of a winged Lion and a winged Bull with a group of 300 men in 1847. He loaded them on a wheeled cart and towed them from Nimrud to the river and loaded on a barge where it was sent to London. Approximately 30 men pulled each ton. [79]
  • Paul Emile Botta and Victor Place attempted to move 2 additional 30 ton colossi to Paris from Khorsabad in 1853. In order to facilitate their shipment to Paris they were sawed in pieces and they still ran into problems. One of them fell into the river into the Tigris never to be retrieved. The other made it to Paris. [80]
  • In a 2001 exercise in experimental archaeology, an attempt was made to transport a large stone along a land and sea route from Wales to Stonehenge. Volunteers pulled it for some miles (with great difficulty) on a wooden sledge over land, using modern roads and low-friction netting to assist sliding, but once transferred to a replica prehistoric boat, the stone sank in Milford Haven, before it even reached the rough seas of the Bristol Channel. [81]
  • Charles Love experimented with a 10-ton replica of a Moai on Easter Island. His first experiment found rocking the statue to walk it was too unstable over more than a few hundred yards. He then found that placing the statue upright on two sled runners atop log rollers, 25 men were able to move the statue 150 feet (46 m) in two minutes. Approximately 2.5 men pulled each ton. [82]
  • Roger Hopkins and Mark Lehrner teamed up with a NOVA crew to conduct a Obelisk erecting experiment, they successfully erected a 25 ton obelisk in late summer of 1999. They also managed to tow it a short distance. [83][84][85]
  • Roger Hopkins and Vince Lee both theorized about how the megalithic stones were moved at Baalbek, these theories involved either towing them or flipping them. [86]
  • Vince Lee participated in experiments to test his theories about how the walls of Sacsayhuamán were built. [87]

[edit] Calculating the weight of megaliths

In the cases of the smaller megaliths it may be possible to weigh them. However in most cases the megaliths were too large or they may have been part of an ancient structure so this method couldn't be used. If you know the volume of a stone and the density you can calculate the weight by multiplying them. The density of most stones is between two and three tons per cubic meter. The average weight of granite is about 2.75 metric tons per cubic meter, limestone 2.3 metric tons per cubic meter, sandstone or marble 2.5tons per metric cubic meter [88] [89][90][91][92]. Some softer stones may be lighter than 2 tons per cubic meter like volcanic tuff or basalt which weighs about 1.9 tons per cubic meter.[93][94] Since the density of most of these stones flucuates it is necessary to know the source for the stone and volume to obtain accurate estimates. In some cases these measurements are close enough to recognize obviously flawed estimates though for example in Fingerprints of the Gods page 58-60 Graham Hancock mentions a monolith around 12 feet (3.7 m) long (3.6 m) by 5 feet (1.5 m) wide (1.5 m) by 5 feet (1.5 m) thick (1.5 m) that could not have "weighed less than 200 tons". This monolith would be about 8.1 cubic meters. A more accurate estimate would be less than 23 metric tons based on these measurements. This is just one of many exaggerated examples that have been provided by some published sources. [95][96]

[edit] Rock Density

The discussion above is accurate as far as it goes, which is only to the first significant figure (viz, "20 tonnes" or "30 tonnes", but not "100 tonnes"). To go any further one needs to be relatively sophisticated about surveying the megalith (including realistic and explicit assessment of the shapes of inaccessible portions of the megalith), then about calculating the volume (and volumetric errors, which vary crudely as the cube of linear uncertainties). Finally and crucially the rock density needs to be measured with appropriate precision. Identifying the rock type is not going to be sufficient - this table (from [2]) illustrates why :

Densities of common rocks
Material Density (gm/cm^3)
Sediments 1.7-2.3
Sandstone 2.0-2.6
Shale 2.0-2.7
Limestone 2.5-2.8
Granite 2.5-2.8
Basalts 2.7-3.1
Metamorphic Rocks 2.6-3.0

Simply identifying the megalith as being "sandstone" would allow a reasonable +/- 15% uncertainty in the weight estimate. In practice, one would really nead to measure the density of the megalith itself, and preferably document any variation in density within the megalith (these are natural materials, not engineered to homogeneous parameters). Non-destructive methods of density measurements are available (e.g. electron back-scatter); alternatively the site may contain already-separated fragments of the megalith which can be used for laboratory measurements or on-site techniques. At the crudest, a weighing device and a bucket can give you two significant figures for your density value.

[edit] Other Lists

[edit] See also

[edit] References

  1. ^ "The Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  2. ^ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2008/03/080331-egypt-statue.html
  3. ^ Alouf, Michael M., 1944: History of Baalbek. American Press. p. 129
  4. ^ "The Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  5. ^ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2008/03/080331-egypt-statue.html
  6. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Ramses II: Magnificence on the Nile (1993)
  7. ^ The History Channel cited the 16.5 depth 567 ton estimate in "Lost Worlds of King Herod"
  8. ^ Dan Bahat: Touching the Stones of our Heritage, Israeli ministry of Religious Affairs, 2002
  9. ^ "The Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  10. ^ http://members.aol.com/Sokamoto31/obelisk.htm
  11. ^ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/egypt/raising/world.html
  12. ^ "The Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  13. ^ Siliotti, Alberto, Zahi Hawass, 1997 "Guide to the Pyramids of Egypt" p.62
  14. ^ Siliotti, Alberto, Zahi Hawass, 1997 "Guide to the Pyramids of Egypt" p.63-9
  15. ^ http://touregypt.net/featurestories/sarapeiona.htm
  16. ^ The Pyramids and Sphinx by Desmond Stewert and editors of the Newsweek Book Division 1971 p. 80-81
  17. ^ http://www2.gol.com/users/stever/asukas.htm
  18. ^ http://www.megalithic.co.uk/search.php?query=&topic=&author=&sitetype=44&county=602&category=&type=stories
  19. ^ "The Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  20. ^ Edwards, Dr. I.E.S.: The Pyramids of Egypt 1986/1947 p. 147-163
  21. ^ source: Edwards, Dr. I.E.S.: The Pyramids of Egypt 1986/1947 p. 175-6, 180-1, 275
  22. ^ [1]
  23. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series:Aztecs: Reign of Blood and Splendor (1992) p.45-47
  24. ^ http://instructional1.calstatela.edu/bevans/Art446-03-Teotihuacan/WebPage-Info.00033.html
  25. ^ http://www.chapala.com/chapala/ojo2006/tlaloc.html
  26. ^ http://sophie-g.net/photo/bret/brest/kerloas01.htm
  27. ^ Edwards, Dr. I.E.S.: The Pyramids of Egypt 1986/1947 p. 246-9
  28. ^ http://www.touregypt.net/featurestories/khendjerp.htm
  29. ^ Browman, D. L., 1981, New light on Andean Tiwanaku. New Scientist. vol. 69, no. 4, pp. 408-419.
  30. ^ Coe, Michael, Dean Snow, and Elizabeth Benson, 1986 "Atlas of Ancient America" p. 190
  31. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  32. ^ Readers Digest: "Mysteries of the Ancient Americas" The New World Before Columbus 1986 p. 220-1
  33. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  34. ^ Edwards, Dr. I.E.S.: The Pyramids of Egypt 1986/1947 p. 237-240
  35. ^ http://www.touregypt.net/featurestories/amenemhet3hp.htm
  36. ^ Siliotti, Alberto, Zahi Hawass, 1997 "Guide to the Pyramids of Egypt"
  37. ^ Weir, A (1980). Early Ireland. A Field Guide. Belfast: Blackstaff Press. pp. p101. 
  38. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  39. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  40. ^ Lehner, Mark The Complete Pyramids, London: Thames and Hudson (1997)p. 148-9 ISBN 0-500-05084-8
  41. ^ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/easter/explore/paro.html
  42. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  43. ^ Walker, Charles, 1980 "Wonders of the Ancient World" p24-7
  44. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Ramses II: Magnificence on the Nile (1993) p. 53-54
  45. ^ http://www.asukanet.gr.jp/asukahome/ASUKA2/ASUKAKOFUN/isibutaiK.html
  46. ^ http://static.monolithic.com/thedome/pantheon/index.html
  47. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  48. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  49. ^ http://www.art-and-archaeology.com/malta/hq7.html
  50. ^ http://www.bradshawfoundation.com/malta/
  51. ^ http://www.cs.colostate.edu/~malaiya/ashoka.html
  52. ^ http://www.archaeology.org/0811/abstracts/turkey.html
  53. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  54. ^ http://www.megalithic.co.uk/article.php?sid=142
  55. ^ Lynne Lancaster,“Building Trajan's Column,” American Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 103, No. 3. (Jul., 1999) p.426
  56. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Ramses II: Magnificence on the Nile (1993)p. 133
  57. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Mesopotamia: The Mighty Kings p118-119
  58. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  59. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Mesopotamia: The Mighty Kings. (1995) p. 112-121
  60. ^ Lost Worlds: The Pagans (of Britain) History Channel series with contributions from historian Prof. Ronald Hutton, Archeologists Erika Guttmann and Martin Carruthers
  61. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  62. ^ Walker, Charles, 1980 "Wonders of the Ancient World" p. 150-3
  63. ^ Aztecs: Reign of Blood and Splendor. Virginia:Time Life, 1992.
  64. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  65. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  66. ^ Lehner, Mark The Complete Pyramids, London: Thames and Hudson (1997)p.196-7 ISBN 0-500-05084-8.
  67. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Southeast Asia: A Past Regained (1995)
  68. ^ "Seventy Wonders of the Ancient World" edited by Chris Scarre 1999
  69. ^ http://www.megalithic.co.uk/article.php?sid=9732&mode=thread&order=0&thold=0
  70. ^ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/2403stone.html
  71. ^ Josh Bernstein: Digging for the Truth p. 133-5 book based on History Chennel series
  72. ^ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/easter/move/past.html
  73. ^ Heyerdahl, Thor Aku-Aku; The 1958 Expedition to Easter Island.
  74. ^ Heyerdahl, Thor. Easter Island - A Mystery Solved. 1988. ISBN 951-30-8952-5
  75. ^ Lehner, Mark The Complete Pyramids, London: Thames and Hudson (1997)p.202-225 ISBN 0-500-05084-8.
  76. ^ Edwards, Dr. I.E.S.: The Pyramids of Egypt 1986/1947 p. 273-4
  77. ^ Lehner, Mark The Complete Pyramids, London: Thames and Hudson (1997)p.224 ISBN 0-500-05084-8.
  78. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Ramses II: Magnificence on the Nile (1993) p. 47-48
  79. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Mesopotamia: The Mighty Kings.(1995) p. 112-121
  80. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Mesopotamia: The Mighty Kings.(1995) p. 112-121
  81. ^ Theories about Stonehenge
  82. ^ John Flenley and Paul G. Bahn (2003). The Enigmas of Easter Island: Island on the Edge, p 150. ISBN 0192803409
  83. ^ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/egypt/dispatches/990827.html
  84. ^ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/egypt/dispatches/990314.html
  85. ^ Time Life Lost Civilizations series: Ramses II: Magnificence on the Nile (1993)p. 56-57
  86. ^ History Channel "Mega Movers: Ancient Mystery Moves"
  87. ^ History Channel "Mega Movers: Ancient Mystery Moves"
  88. ^ Kumagai, Naoichi; Sadao Sasajima, Hidebumi Ito (15 February 1978). "Long-term Creep of Rocks: Results with Large Specimens Obtained in about 20 Years and Those with Small Specimens in about 3 Years". Journal of the Society of Materials Science (Japan) (Japan Energy Society) 27 (293): 157–161. http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=ja&u=http://ci.nii.ac.jp/naid/110002299397/&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=4&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DIto%2BHidebumi%26hl%3Den. Retrieved on 2008-06-16. 
  89. ^ http://palm.sri.com/palm/tasks/6-8/Dminerals/directs.html
  90. ^ http://strata.geol.sc.edu/terminology/densitylog.html
  91. ^ http://meteorites.wustl.edu/id/density.htm
  92. ^ http://www.eurostonemarble.com/tips.htm
  93. ^ http://www.albarrie.com/techfabrics/continuousfiber.aspx
  94. ^ http://www.osti.gov/energycitations/product.biblio.jsp?osti_id=5461391
  95. ^ http://www.onekama.k12.mi.us/m2001/mwarman/warman00/dens_calculating.htm
  96. ^ http://www.onekama.k12.mi.us/onekama98-99/gr6/density.htm
Personal tools
Languages

Visit joltnews for the latest headlines
Visit bloit.com for company information
Geed Media does computer consulting on long island.
This page viewed times. See Logs